Australian National University Logo
Australian National University Logo

Exam types at ANU: Who might be disadvantaged?

In this collection

  1. Exam types at ANU: Who might be disadvantaged?
  2. Principles of inclusive exam design
  3. Designing inclusive exams
  4. Designing alternative arrangements in exams
  5. Inclusive exam design checklist

This suite of resources supports academic and professional staff in designing and implementing exams that are inclusive, equitable, and aligned with inclusive assessment principles at ANU. The collection includes:

  • Exam types at ANU: Who might be disadvantaged?
  • Principles of inclusive exam design
  • Designing inclusive exams
  • Designing alternative arrangements to exams
  • Inclusive exam design checklist

Exams at ANU can be broadly categorised into several types. When exams are traditionally designed around assumptions of a normal, able student, they can unintentionally disadvantage or exclude certain student groups (Nieminen, 2024). In this section, we examine the different categories of exams at ANU, explore the characteristics and needs of diverse student cohorts, consider how the design and requirements of each exam type may inadvertently assess factors beyond intended learning outcomes, and create potential risks of exclusion.

1. Invigilated face-to-face exams

Many courses at ANU use final and mid-term exams as key assessment tasks. When designing an exam, it is important to first consider why it is being used and whether it is the most appropriate way to assess the achievement of intended learning outcomes in your course. We should remember that if a final exam is already in place, using a mid-term exam in quite similar assessment conditions might limit students’ opportunity to demonstrate the full extent of learning. To consider exams against other more authentic assessment options, we can ask ourselves the following questions:

  • What academic integrity risks am I trying to address through this exam?
  • Am I imposing restrictions that are not necessary?
  • Could alternative assessment designs address integrity concerns more effectively?

If we want to conduct these exams in a secure, invigilated assessment environment, we should ask ourselves:

  • Why does this exam need to be secure?
  • Does the level of invigilation match the stakes of the assessment?

When an exam is the most appropriate choice, it should be designed and implemented in a way that meets its intended purposes and minimises unnecessary barriers for students who might be affected (CAST, 2024).

Key inclusion considerations for invigilated timed exams

Exam performance can be affected by factors unrelated to subject knowledge, reducing the validity of results. Some considerations for supervised, timed exams are outlined below, based on Tai et al. (2023) and French et al. (2024):

  • Timed exams tend to favour students who can rapidly focus and maintain concentration under pressure.
  • Strict time limits may disadvantage students with physical, cognitive, or neurodivergent conditions.
  • Handwritten exams can disadvantage students who experience difficulties with handwriting speed, legibility, or fine motor skills.
  • High-stakes (Final) exams can increase stress and anxiety, which may negatively affect performance.
  • Students with autism, ADHD, learning disabilities, sensory processing differences, or mental health conditions may face additional barriers in traditional exam settings.
  • Students with physical health conditions may find it difficult to remain seated for long periods.
  • Large exam venues may create challenges due to noise, crowded environments, and constant invigilation.

Inclusion snapshot

What this exam may unintentionally measure

  • Processing speed
  • Handwriting speed
  • Exam anxiety
  • Physical stamina
  • Ability to perform in large exam halls

How exclusion may occur

Some students may not be able to demonstrate learning effectively under highly controlled conditions.

Who may be affected

  • Students with ADHD
  • Students with dyslexia
  • Autistic students
  • Students with anxiety disorders
  • Students with chronic health conditions (e.g., physical disability, sensory disability, or combinations of these)
  • Students using assistive technology
  • Students with some neurodivergent conditions
  • Students whose first language is not English
  • Students who have a combination of these characteristics

2. Online proctored exams (Proctorio)

ANU uses Proctorio, integrated within Canvas, as its online invigilation platform to support academic integrity in online exams. Research shows that while many students appreciate the convenience of online proctored exams, there are reported concerns about the intrusive nature of online monitoring, fear for privacy violations, technical issues, and difficulties in finding suitable spaces for these exams (Milione et al., 2017). These challenges may affect students with disabilities, health conditions, caring responsibilities or those who use assistive technology or have limited access to technology or appropriate study spaces.

Inclusion snapshot

What this exam may unintentionally measure

  • Technology quality
  • Internet reliability
  • Availability of webcam/microphone, comfort with surveillance
  • Ability to remain still
  • Home environment suitability

How exclusion may occur

These exams may unintentionally measure technology access, privacy, or behaviour rather than learning.

Who may be affected

  • Students with unreliable internet
  • Students using older devices
  • Students with limited financial resources
  • Students with disabilities
  • Students with mental health conditions
  • Students using assistive technology
  • Neurodivergent students
  • Students who have a combination of these characteristics

3. Timed online exams

ANU academics also manage arrangements of final online exams during the exam period. Like proctored online exams, there are certain benefits of these online exams compared to traditional face-to-face exams delivered in invigilated venues. However, there are also potential risks of exclusion to certain student groups. Issues about digital literacy, Internet access, compatibility to screen-readers or the ability to manage online systems may affect students with diverse learning or health needs. Again, these exams raise questions about what we should do to remove these barriers to create a more inclusive exam experience for ANU students.

Inclusion snapshot

What this exam may unintentionally measure

  • Digital literacy
  • Internet access
  • Screen-reading ability
  • Typing speed
  • Ability to manage online systems

How exclusion may occur

Technical barriers may interfere with the exam performance of some student groups.

Who may be affected

  • Students with poor internet connectivity
  • Regional or remote students
  • Students using older devices
  • Students using assistive technology
  • Students with low vision
  • Students with some cognitive disabilities
  • Students who have a combination of these characteristics

4. Quizzes

Quizzes are typically short, online assessments that are often automatically marked. Regular quizzes support deeper and longer knowledge retention than single, high-stakes exams (French et al., 2024). Frequent low-stakes quizzes can reduce pressure, with multiple opportunities for students to demonstrate learning. Quizzes can also provide immediate feedback and are commonly used in tutorials to support learning or contribute a small proportion of the final grade.

However, frequent quizzes, such as weekly quizzes, can create academic pressure and may be exclusive to those whose performances are affected by chronic stress, anxiety, illness or contemporary circumstances. Quiz formats often privilege students with rapid recall and recognition abilities and disadvantage those with dyslexia, visual impairments, and other disabilities if accessibility considerations are not incorporated into quiz design.

Inclusion snapshot

What this exam may unintentionally measure

  • Reading speed
  • Test-taking strategies
  • Rapid recall
  • Availability at fixed times

How exclusion may occur

Frequent quizzes may create a cumulative burden and favour students who are available regularly and comfortable with quiz formats.

Who may be affected

Speed and test-taking difficulties:

  • Neurodivergent students
  • Students whose first language is not English

Frequency requirements:

  • Students with caring responsibilities
  • Students in paid employment
  • Students managing health conditions
  • Students experiencing episodic disability

Online mode:

  • Students with poor internet connectivity
  • Regional or remote students
  • Students using older devices
  • Students using assistive technology
  • Students with low vision
  • Students with some cognitive disabilities

5. Oral exams

Oral final exams are also an important assessment type at ANU. They can provide authentic learning and assessment experiences by replicating authentic professional practices in specific professions such as clinical consultations, client interviews, or project briefings. They provide valuable opportunities for academics to evaluate students’ achievement of graduate attributes, including critical thinking and oral communication skills. They also enable examiners to probe students’ understanding in real time, ask follow-up questions, and clarify misunderstanding. Most importantly, this assessment type is often valued for its ability to reduce the possibility of academic misconduct and strengthen academic integrity.

However, as with any other assessment method, the decision to use oral exams should be driven by intended learning outcomes rather than concerns about academic misconduct alone. If oral communication is a core learning outcome, this might be an appropriate method. Otherwise, this choice of assessment may disadvantage students with speech, language or communication difficulties, neurodivergent students, students with anxiety, or students whose English is an additional language, causing unnecessary stress that is not linked with learning outcomes.

Inclusion snapshot

What this exam may unintentionally measure

  • Prior experience with oral assessment expectations
  • Confidence in speaking under pressure
  • Fluency in English

How exclusion may occur

Students may be disadvantaged if they are not familiar with oral assessment formats or have limited practice opportunities.

Neurodivergent students may experience increasing anxiety that affects their performance.

Who may be affected

  • First-year students
  • International students whose first language is not English
  • First-in-family students
  • Neurodivergent students
  • Students with speech, language and communication difficulties
  • Students using assistive technology

6. Take-home exams

Take-home exams are also a choice of assessment methods at ANU. These exams are excellent exam options when it comes to inclusive assessment practices by reducing students’ exam-related anxiety, enabling them to engage with authentic real-world problems and allowing them to access resources and have peer support (Bengtsson, 2019; Tai et al., 2023).

However, take-home exams, usually administered within a strict and rigid timeframe, can also assess unintended factors and risk excluding some students. Performance in these exams can be influenced by other factors such as technological access, textbook access, access to academic, peer or familial support, time management, and self-regulation strategies. Many students with difficulties in executive functioning abilities, students with chronic health conditions, and those with barriers to digital resources may find it challenging to perform effectively in these exams.

Inclusion snapshot

What this exam may unintentionally measure

  • Access to resources
  • Availability of time
  • Digital access to technology
  • Self-regulating ability

How exclusion may occur

Students may be disadvantaged if they cannot access resources to engage in the tasks, have work or family commitments or are unfamiliar with executive functioning activities independently.

Who may be affected

  • Students with ADHD
  • Autistic students
  • Students with anxiety disorders
  • Students with caring responsibilities
  • Students in paid employment
  • Students managing health conditions
  • Students experiencing episodic disability
  • Students with poor internet connectivity
  • Regional or remote students
  • Students using older devices
  • Students using assistive technology
  • Students with low vision
  • Students with some cognitive disabilities

Key messages

  • No exam type is inherently inclusive or exclusive.

Each exam type can support or disadvantage different groups of students depending on how it is designed and implemented. When selecting an exam type, it is important to establish firm goals driven by desired learning outcomes, consider how different groups of students may experience the assessment, and proactively remove unnecessary barriers so that performance can reflect students’ actual knowledge and skills.

  • Flexibility can improve inclusion without compromising academic standards.

Clearly, flexibility in format, timing, conditions, resources, or question design can help students achieve the same learning outcomes while maintaining equivalent academic standards. Firm goals, flexible means.

  • Accessibility should be considered from the outset.

Exam design that anticipates diversity from the beginning is more effective than retrofitting adjustments later for a specific group of students.

  • Students may require support before, during and after exams.

Students need support at different stages of their exam experience. Before exams, they benefit from clear communication about expectations, practice opportunities, and timely feedback. During exams, they may require accessible materials, reasonable adjustments, and assistive technologies. After exams, students may need access to feedback and information about next steps such as clarification, a review or an appeal in relation to exams.

  • Inclusive exam design benefits all students.

Inclusive exam design is not only beneficial for students with Education Access Plans (EAPs), Extenuating Circumstances Applications (ECAs) or those with specific support needs. Designing exams that are clear, accessible and aligned with learning outcomes clearly improves the assessment experience for the entire student cohort.

Further resources

1 Helpful assessment websites and policies at ANU:

Assessment and Exams website

Extenuating Circumstances Application website

Policy: Students Assessment (coursework)

Procedure: Student Assessment (coursework)

2 Curtin University: Inclusive Exam: Assessment Case Study

3 University of Leeds: Designing Inclusive Assessments

4 ADCET: Assessments and Exams

References

Bengtsson, L. (2019). Take-home exams in higher education: A systematic review. Education Sciences, 9(4), 267.

Center for Applied Special Technology. (2024). Universal Design for Learning Guidelines 3.0. CAST.

French, S., Dickerson, A., & Mulder, R. A. (2024). A review of the benefits and drawbacks of high-stakes final examinations in higher education. Higher Education, 88(3), 893-918.

Milone, A. S., Cortese, A. M., Balestrieri, R. L., & Pittenger, A. L. (2017). The impact of proctored online exams on the educational experience. Currents in Pharmacy Teaching and Learning, 9(1), 108-114.

Nieminen, J. H. (2024). Assessment for inclusion: Rethinking inclusive assessment in higher education. Teaching in Higher Education, 29(4), 841-859.

Tai, J., Mahoney, P., Ajjawi, R., Bearman, M., Dargusch, J., Dracup, M., & Harris, L. (2023). How are examinations inclusive for students with disabilities in higher education? A sociomaterial analysis. Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education, 48(3), 390-402.

Last updated: